What the heck happens when Manzella comes off the DL?

There's a big decision coming when 27-year old Tommy Manzella is eligible to return from the DL: Play him, or play 26-year old Angel Sanchez?

Let's look, shall we?

Name	PAs	Avg/SLG/OBP	K:BB	XBH-RBI	SB/Err
Manzella	209	.212/.259/.254	57:10	6-16	0/8
Sanchez	128	.291/.331/.376	22:6	8-14	0/2

Some key splits to consider:

Against RHPs:

Name	PAs	Avg/SLG/OBP	K:BB	XBH-RBI	BABIP
Manzella	164	.168/.211/.201	54:6	3-11	.247
Sanchez	84	.262/.311/.369	12:5	7-11	.306

Against LHPs:

Name	PAs	Avg/SLG/OBP	K:BB	XBH-RBI	BABIP
Manzella	45	.375/.432/.450	3:4	3-5	.405
Sanchez	38	.333/.351/.361	10:1	1-3	.462

w/RISP:

Name	PAs	Avg/SLG/OBP	K:BB	XBH-RBI	BABIP
Manzella	53	.196/.245/.239	14:4	2-14	.257
Sanchez	35	.233/.303/.367	4:2	3-14	.269

Is this a definitive look? Hell, and no, it's not. Are we dealing with a ridiculously small sample size? Hell, and yes, we are. But at least they're comparable sample sizes. I give the edge to Sanchez, but I'm also not sure what you do with Manzella.